Search Stoves & Reviews

Pellet Stove Reviews - Archive

Browse Stove Reviews Contributed by Wise Heat Visitors

Quadra-Fire Mt Vernon AE
Review and ratings contributed by Larry Higgins on Nov 04, 2018

Won’t start, won’t run worth af, put hundreds into it. Basically, a piece of shit. And this review Is bullshit cause it defaults to “5” as soon as you hit submit. Just send me the “engineer” that designed it.

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Sante Fe
Review and ratings contributed by whit on Oct 27, 2018

I've had this stove since 2009, burning 3 tons a year. Replaced the door gasket a couple of years ago, and the auger motor, which had been straining audibly for a couple of years, this year. Should have done that earlier. It runs much better with the new one, which is OEM but a different make than ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman Accentra
Review and ratings contributed by Sullivanclan on Oct 07, 2018

We purchased the freestanding model and had it installed by the local company three years ago for our two stories 1,400 ft home in Colorado. We are super happy with it. In our milder Western climate, we burn a pallet each winter. I clean it well once a year. No problems thus far, great automatic ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Sante Fe
Review and ratings contributed by Dave on Oct 03, 2018

Had a Quadra Fire Santa Fe ($2500)since 2008. Been running 2.5 tons a year through it. So far a control box ($300+) An exhaust blower($200) and a convection blower ($200) have failed and needed replacement. My $1100 England stove in my workshop has needed one auger motor($125) since 2008. Don't buy ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman Accentra
Review and ratings contributed by ctl on Sep 15, 2018

I reviewed this stove on Feb. 19, 2016. It was regarding the warping and cracking of the cast center medallion after only 3 seasons of use. We just had a technician from the stove shop from whom we bought the stove come to do a thorough cleaning. (9/13/2018) After only 2 1/2 seasons of use, the ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman P68
Review and ratings contributed by Ms. Cory Willets Haigh Phillips cawh55@gmail.com on Jul 28, 2018

I am a Female... now 63 yrs old. I have owned, operated & maintained my 1999 P60 (60K BTUs w/ MANUAL ignition) pellet stove -EVERY Year since 2001 -BY Myself!!! I Bought it for $2400. This P60 is soooo reliable!!! I LOVE Harman's QUALITY!!! I live alone in N.NH. I need a RELIABLE source of ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman XXV
Review and ratings contributed by Dennis on Jun 17, 2018

Had this stove for almost 8 years. I hear my house with it in Ct all winter long. The main issue I did wrong with it originally was to turn the sensitivity all the way up. This caused the secondary fans to come on very quickly, increasing the noise and using more pellets. Once I dialed it down, the ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Breckwell P2000FS
Review and ratings contributed by WAMmacp on Feb 20, 2018

I have been using this stove since 2003. Once I figured out how to use it, it has worked great. Not a mechanical problem in the first 13 years. Had to replace convection blower 2years ago and the auger motor this year. Can't complain after 15 years!! Love it!

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Mt Vernon AE
Review and ratings contributed by Lab Lover on Jan 10, 2018

Bought this AE in early 2017. Full use started in November, 8 months later. "Dealer" is a one-man shop; service response from him is HORRIBLE. Worse. Called Quadra Fire direct and complained about their dealer's lack of service, stove quit working completely after thermostat started ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman XXV
Review and ratings contributed by Cold in Vermont on Jan 07, 2018

I have had this stove for 5 years and it's BTU output has never come close to advertised. My much cheaper Enviro rated at 35,000 btu's blows this Harman away. Very Expensive Pretty looking stove - but very inefficient (much of the heat goes out the chimney); not functional, very small ash pan which ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Castile
Review and ratings contributed by David Gunderman on Dec 30, 2017

I bought one of these stoves this is the biggest pieces of junk I ever owned I had it about 10 years I've yet to get to run a whole season Don't buy this Junk you will hate your self There a money Pit

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Castile
Review and ratings contributed by Mary on Dec 29, 2017

I have had this stove about ten years. I have always found it difficult to clean, and finicky to operate. I just had it professionally cleaned (and serviced) two days ago, for $200. The result? I am listening to whistling noise from the fan. On top of that, on higher settings the flame has been too ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Mt Vernon AE
Review and ratings contributed by Bill Bankard on Dec 27, 2017

I bought our Mt Vernon stove Feb of 2003 and have burned pellets mixed with pea coal every year in Maryland. The heat pump is the backup to the pellet stove. I have had to replace the following : Control board (upgraded), Combustion and Blower motor bearings (upgraded to better bearings) , Door ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman XXV
Review and ratings contributed by Brian R on Dec 27, 2017

Hi There, I have had this stove going on 6 years now, I live in NH and burn about 4 to 5 tons a season. I see a lot of comments on here about the squealing noise. This is how you need to fix that noise, take the 2 back covers off with the stove off and unplugged. Locate the auger and the motor on ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Enviro Empress
Review and ratings contributed by Dan on Dec 21, 2017

DO NOT BUY. This pellet stove is a piece of crap. WAY to expensive.!st year it worked okay, 2nd year had to clean it out which is a major pain in the butt,have to pull it out from the wall (it's heavy). Did not work the second time I tried to use it. Had to call a service man to fix it. Now it's ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Avalon Arbor
Review and ratings contributed by T1954ying@aol.com on Dec 14, 2017

I purchased this stove Oct 2008. I burn two tons of pellets, 100 - 40 lb bags a year every year since purchased. Some pellets have too much ash but I have found one I like and I special order them every year before the heating season. I typically clean the firebox every 10 bags. As the stove clogs ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Classic Bay 1200
Review and ratings contributed by cynthia coash on Dec 11, 2017

I bought this three years ago. The first one wouldn't run past 1 day so after contacting owner of business they brought me another one. !0 days after warranty ran out on exhaust fan the bearing went out they wanted 500.00 to fix it and it would take a month before they could come. Then 20 days ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Castile
Review and ratings contributed by Rayod on Nov 29, 2017

Really REALLY noisy. Runs only at full high speed, heats to about ten degrees above setting, then shuts down, leaving cold pocket for hours. Stupid, stupid, stupid. Should cycle into lower setting, keep warm, allow for comfort. Less comfortable, rather than more. Wish we jad never installed.

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman Accentra
Review and ratings contributed by Bill on Nov 26, 2017

This is our 4th season with this insert. It works great and haven't had any issues with it. We have a 1800 sq ft 2 story Cape. It keeps the whole house between 68 and 70 degrees . It burns 1 bag a day average . We use about 3 tons a year. I scrap the burn pot everyday and clean the stove after ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Breckwell Classic Cast
Review and ratings contributed by tom on Nov 22, 2017

I have had my breckwell p4000 since 2008, and the only thing I have ever replaced is the brick panel set. It gives me plenty of heat and I am glad I invested in it.

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Breckwell Classic Cast
Review and ratings contributed by tom redding on Nov 22, 2017

I have had my breckwell p4000 since 2008, and the only thing I have ever replaced is the brick panel set. It give me plenty of head and 5 am glad I invested in it.

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Sante Fe
Review and ratings contributed by Johnson on Nov 10, 2017

Had the stove for three years. Each year something has gone wrong with it at least once. I change the brakes on my car and maintain my boat, so I am reasonably competent, but this stove is a continuing source of frustration. The auger motor is the most common problem, it stops until I remove it, ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman Accentra
Review and ratings contributed by John S. on Nov 08, 2017

Worthless junk....nothing but troubles and problems and blowing out lukewarm air at best. Do yourself a favor and get a wood burning stove if you want heat and a fraction of the problems.....DO NOT WASTE MONEY ON THIS GARBAGE!!!!!!!!!

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Classic Bay 1200
Review and ratings contributed by Unhappy-in-PA on Nov 07, 2017

purchased in 2015 from Kring's Home and Hearth...first insert installed had to be immediately replaced by the dealer because "It couldn't be fixed !" Second unit is nothing but problems, and the dealer is useless... it is nearly rusted out, soon to be dangerous to operate (after one ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
NU-TEC Upland 207
Review and ratings contributed by Curt in Alaska on Nov 04, 2017

I researched pellet stoves on the internet for some time before I bought the Nu Tech Upland 207. I was swept up by all the rave reviews so purchased the stove and paid to ship it to Alaska. We finally got our home finished and installed the stove. What a beauty it is. To say we like this stove ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Classic Bay 1200
Review and ratings contributed by Independent Pellet Tech on Oct 14, 2017

Most complaints about this store stem from issues that aren’t the stoves fault. All pellet stoves need maintenance on a daily, weekly, monthly and annual basis. You also need to keep the stove dry. The quality of the pellet greatly affects performance and protecting it with a surge protector is ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman P68
Review and ratings contributed by sans123 on Sep 04, 2017

I love love this stove. I'm getting another pellet stove and was considering an insert plus other harman models. The feedback on the other models aren't as good,so I think I will be purchasing another P68. I will say the type of pellets one burns is important. Except for cleaning, which is a ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman Accentra
Review and ratings contributed by Frustrated on May 04, 2017

After 1- 1/2 years we do not have an insert in our fireplace.. We have replaced igniter, fuse, and still have no stove. The co. We purchased this from , on orders from Harman, have taken our stove back to "the shop" to go over it with a fine toothed comb.. This has been going on for over ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman Accentra
Review and ratings contributed by Dave on Apr 27, 2017

We bought our Harman Accentra Freestanding Pellet Stove in December 2014, and we are still very happy with it. We live in Connecticut and have a raised ranch with electric heat. We bought a Quadrafire Mt Vernon in 2008 for the down stairs and it did a good job of heating most of our home (we love ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Breckwell P2700FS
Review and ratings contributed by Charlie on Apr 06, 2017

I have had my stove for many years and it has been fantastic. I have replaced the exhaust fan and the limit switch. My stove runs 24/7 from November to April. The only time it is shut down is for cleaning. In ten plus years of service, I will call that very reliable.

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Breckwell Classic Cast
Review and ratings contributed by Joe on Feb 28, 2017

I've had my p4000 since 2012, have put in 2 combustion motors, 2 convection motors, proof of fire switch, high limit switch, had the control board fixed, and have to clean it it almost daily. Breckwell says tough kitty, and never has replaced one part. Today it made a big bang, turned off. who ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Napoleon NPS40
Review and ratings contributed by C in Connecticut on Feb 24, 2017

Purchased on Ebay about 8-9 years ago,2008-2009, New for $1400 w/ free shipping. Used 4 tons a year, on install,Disconnected ignitor ,oiled motors, hooked exhaust/intake etc, little fluid on pellets in pot and light. Cleaned well every year and oiled all motors, capped exhaust/intake every spring ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Classic Bay 1200
Review and ratings contributed by Mark on Jan 19, 2017

Poor product, and worse service!! I purchased a quadrafire 1200 pellet stove on the 9 of Dec 2016.The 2nd of January it quit working. The first time when I called they told me to look at the fuse, so I took the covers off to get to the fuse. It was blown, I made a 100 mile round trip to get the ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Classic Bay 1200
Review and ratings contributed by Mark on Jan 19, 2017

Poor product, and worse service!! I purchased a quadrafire 1200 pellet stove on the 9 of Dec 2016.The 2nd of January it quit working. The first time when I called they told me to look at the fuse, so I took the covers off to get to the fuse. It was blown, I made a 100 mile round trip to get the ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Mt Vernon AE
Review and ratings contributed by Pudaloo on Jan 12, 2017

may I just say this stove is a VERY EXPENSIVE PIECE OF CRAP!! It is very expensive to operate, very dirty, dusty, noisy, keeps breaking down. I'm thinking, dear God what else can go wrong with this piece of crap? Try to fix it yourself? Good luck. Right now we are freezing because the afore ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Enviro Empress
Review and ratings contributed by Spokes0831 on Jan 09, 2017

I bought this stove brand new in 2008 and it has been nothing but a headache since. After initial installation, I had the service team at my house on a regular basis. They could never seem to find what the problem was, and actually told.me they were going to claim mine as a "lemon". ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Classic Bay 1200
Review and ratings contributed by 36flatie on Dec 30, 2016

I had this stove for many years never a problem cleaned it on a regular basis gives me plenty of heat I try to get the better pellets when available

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Quadra-Fire Classic Bay 1200
Review and ratings contributed by Crowdednet on Dec 30, 2016

Do not buy this stove. Per the manufacturer it is "normal" for the blower to not come on for 40 minutes, but their literature states up to 20 minutes. That does nothing but burn pellets. But that is not the only reason. My stove was installed last month - lo and behold I stopped using ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman Accentra
Review and ratings contributed by Bill on Dec 24, 2016

Can't believe the negative reports here! Who posted these? Harmon's competitors? I have bought mine in 2008. Had one igniter burn out. That's it!! Love this stove and would recommend it to anyone.

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...
Harman Advance
Review and ratings contributed by Patrick M Palermo on Dec 19, 2016

I had my Harman advance since 2000. I have put in one blower motor and one feeder motor. It runs great from October to march every year. It will burn any kind of pellet with the right adjustment. I lite it with touch fuel so it doesn't flame up . You do need to clean after every 2 tons to ...

Complete review & ratings...
Follow this thread...